Why is jigsaw evil

Enjoy the day, you psychotic nincompoop. Even Billy the Saw puppet gives a big whiny speech in this one. Evil dolls are meant to be full of poltergeists, not hurt feelings. The Film: Shambolic fourth film that finds Kramer playing killer games from beyond the grave.

Step forward Detective Hoffman. I have some criticisms for Hoffman, and then some for the group of Jigsaw killers, as there are now three of them and it can be a real drag keeping up with who has done what and why.

Hoffman is a massive douchebag to everyone, but particularly to the audience. This is a new low for team Jigsaw. We need to trust the score to tell us how to feel, especially after your hyper gory violent films have deadened our emotions. The Saw team are still being led by Jigsaw from beyond the grave.

Rigg, a troubled cop, is being taught to cherish his life by letting criminals die. Jigsaw is trying to show us that saving the wrong person is a mistake. I think this might be Kramer projecting after an extended period of working with Amanda. Jigsaw then attempts to teach Rigg to be angry at criminals, which he already is. Elsewhere, the detectives trying to solve the Jigsaw case in Saw IV are aggressively pursuing the killers using a method many of us will recognize as wild, baseless speculation.

Thank god someone in this series is being a douchebag for a good cause. Meanwhile, Hoffman attempts to cover his tracks while receiving acclaim for catching the Jigsaw killer. Meanwhile, Detective Strahm believes he is closing in on the real Jigsaw killer. Overstuffed sequel. In that scene, Jigsaw sets up a trap designed to teach Detective Strahm not to be a detective. What is Hoffman even doing at this point? Strahm wakes up with his head in a glass box that starts filling with water, receiving no instructions or explanation.

As far as I can tell, Jigsaw is also trying to teach him to be thirsty. Finally, Hoffman gets the better of Strahm at the end of the film. The first game the new group of victims have to face in Saw V , a weird collar, head choppy set-up, is so overly complicated that Jigsaw had to set his tape recorder to long play to just to fit his instructions on one side of the cassette. I agree with them. In another flashback we find out what it is that attracted Kramer to working with Hoffman in the first place, though.

Hoffman and Billy the Saw Puppet have the same hair. Hoffman reminds Kramer of his puppet. The Film: Team Jigsaw puts an insurance executive through the ringer, while Hoffman scrambles to stay ahead of the game. The biggest issue here is that Hoffman continues to speak to everyone in Jigsawisms. Everything the guy says is a dour insistence that we all appreciate life.

Users questions. Is jigsaw good or evil? Is jigsaw a hero? Is jigsaw a killer? Is jigsaw based on a real person? Why did Amanda kill Adam in Saw? Just know it will not save your son if you do. Eric Matthews: You kill my son, I kill you. John Kramer: Go ahead. Why wait? We both know the sort of person you are, sir.

The sort of person who guns down an unarmed suspect. In fact, the sort of person who plants evidence in order to obtain a conviction. The sort of person whose wife leaves him and his son hates him. You may not remember me, but I most certainly remember you.

I was a guest Lynn Denlon: Where am I? John Kramer: Do you remember me? Lawrence Gordon was your doctor. John Kramer: I was his patient and he was mine.

As you can see from that report, my prognosis isn't good. Would you agree? Lynn: There's no preventative treatment for what you have.

John Kramer: I remember you saying that to me once before in almost the exact same tone. Leave it to a doctor to find such a cold, clinical way of saying I'm dead man walking. Looking at me, how long would you say I have left? Lynn: I'd have to examine you. Even then, a frontal lobe tumor is unpredictable. The growth depends on the rate of mitosis versus apoptosis and- John Kramer: I'm sorry, but is all this crude medical equipment around me causing you to believe that you're still inside a hospital?

Lynn: No. John Kramer: Then why are you speaking to me in that graduate-school medical jargon? Now you look at me. I asked you a simple question: Based on your experience, how long do you think I have left?

Lynn: It's not a simple answer. Based on your file, I'd say John Kramer: Death is a surprise party. Unless, of course, you're already dead on the inside. Unless you're the type of person who swallows antidepressants to hide the pain. Turns their backs on their husband and neglects their child; who has every possible advantage in life but chooses not to advance. John Kramer: What do I want? I want to play a game. The rules of the game are simple. The consequences for breaking them are great; death.

You are being tested. Your will is being tested, your will to keep someone alive. Can you do that? Can you follow the rules and grant someone the gift of life? Lynn: What is this?! No, get it-! The second that heart rate monitor flatlines, or you move out of range, an explosion will go off in that collar. Your life and my life will end simultaneously.

Lynn: Please. Please don't do this to me. I have a family. Amanda: Let me give you the simple version: you will keep him alive, whatever it takes. No excuses, no equivocations; no crying.

Lynn: What do you mean, "Keep him alive? A man. He will face a series of tests [Arms two shells] You have to keep John alive until he makes it through. John Kramer: You're a vital piece of my puzzle, Dr. A critical part of what could be my final test. Amanda, it's time to start our game. You need to abide by those rules. Do not be afraid.

Your life has just begun. You haven't seen anything yet. Make our choice. I will judge you You're probably wondering where you are. I'll tell you where you might be. You might be in the room you die in. Up until now you simply sat in the shadows watching others live out their lives. But what do voyeurs see when they look into the mirror?

Now, I see you as a strange mix of someone angry, yet apathetic. But mostly just pathetic. So are you going to watch yourself die today, Adam, or do something about it? Gordon, this is your wake-up call. Every day of your working life you have given people the news that they're going to die soon. Now, you will be the cause of death. Your aim in this game is to kill Adam.

You have until six on the clock to do it. There's a man in the room with you. When there's that much poison in your blood, the only thing left to do -- is shoot yourself. There are ways to win this hidden all around you. Just remember, X marks the spot for the treasure.

If you do not kill Adam by six, then Alison and Diana will die, Dr. Let the game begin. You are a perfectly healthy, sane and middle-class male. Yet last month you ran a straight razor across your wrist. Did you cut yourself because you truly wanted to die, or did you just want some attention? Tonight, you'll show me. The irony is that if you want to die you just have to stay where you are, but if you want to live, you'll have to cut yourself again.

Find the path through the razor-wire to the door. But hurry. At three o'clock that door will lock, and then, this room becomes your tomb.

How much blood will you shed to stay alive, Paul? If you are so sick, then why do I have so many photos of you up and about? Let's put your so-called "illness" to the test. Right now, there's a slow acting poison in your veins. The antidote is inside the safe; the combination to the safe is written on the wall.

Hurry up and program it in, but watch your step. By the way, that's a flammable substance smeared on your body, so I would be careful with that candle if I were you You don't know me, but I know you. Here's what happens if you lose. The device you are wearing is hooked into your upper and lower jaw. When the timer in the back goes off, your mouth will be permanently ripped open. Think of it like a reverse bear trap. Here, I'll show you. It's in the stomach of your dead cell mate. Look around, Amanda.

Know that I'm not lying. You better hurry up. Live or die. You are still alive. Most people are so ungrateful to be alive. But not you. Not anymore. Or as they called you around the hospital: Zepp. I want you to make a choice. There's a slow-acting poison coursing through your system, which only I have the antidote for. Will you murder a mother and her child to save yourself? Listen carefully, if you will.

There are rules. So far, in what loosely could be called your life, you have made a living watching others. Society would call you an informant, a rat, a snitch. I call you unworthy of the body you possess. Of the life you've been given. Now we will see if you are willing to look inward, rather than outward, to give up the one thing you rely on in order to go on living.

The device around your neck is a death mask. The mask is on a string timer. If you do not locate the key in time, the mask will close. Think of it like a Venus Flytrap.

What you're looking at right now is your own body, not more than two hours ago. Don't worry. You're sound asleep, and can't feel a thing. Taking into account that you are at a great disadvantage here, I am going to give you a hint as to where I have hidden the key.

So listen carefully. The hint is this: [TV screen shows an x-ray. How much blood would you shed to stay alive, Michael? Live or die, make your choice. I trust that you are all wondering where you are. I can assure you that while your location is not important, what these walls offer you is important: salvation, if you earn it.

Three hours from now, the door to this house will open. Unfortunately, you only have two hours to live. Right now, you are breathing in a deadly nerve agent. You've been breathing it since you arrived here. Those of you familiar with the Tokyo subway attacks will know its devastating effects on the human body.

The only way to overcome it and walk out that door is to find an antidote. Several are hidden around this house. One is inside the safe in front of you. You all possess the combination to the safe. Think hard. The numbers are in the back of your mind.

The clue to their order can be found over the rainbow. Once you realize what you all have in common, you will gain a better understanding of why you're here. X marks the spot for that clue, so look carefully. For years you have burned those around you with your lies, cons, and deceits. Now you will have a chance to redeem yourself, for the games you've played with others, by playing one of mine. Inside the device in front of you are two antidotes for the poison coursing through your veins.

One is my gift to you for helping me kidnap the others. The second is yours to donate. However, one will come with a price. Remember Obi: Once you are in Hell, only the devil can help you out. The game I want to play is very similar to the game you've been playing as a drug dealer. The game of offering hope to the desperate, for a price. I think we can agree that your situation is desperate. So, I offer you hope. The price you pay is that you must crawl into the same pit of squalor you force your customers into.

By entering this room, you have started a timer. When the timer expires, the door in front of you will be locked forever.

Only in finding the key before the timer runs out can you unlock it and retrieve the antidote inside. I will give you just one hint where to that key is: It will be like finding a needle in a haystack. This game will take place in a room not much bigger than the one you've spent most of your life in: a prison cell. Despite all of the advantages and privileges that you were given at birth, you have returned to prison again and again.

More comfortable in chains than you are in freedom? Tonight, we will see how far you are willing to go to break those chains once and for all. Live or die, Troy. Up until now, you have spent your life among the dead, piecing together their final moments.

You're good at this because you, like them, are also dead. Dead on the inside. You identify more with a cold corpse than you do a living human. I believe you want to join your true family - indeed your only family - in death. The device you are wearing is hooked into your ribcage. And by the time this tape has finished, you will have one minute to find a way out. At the end of that minute There is a single key that will unlock the harness, Kerry.

It's right in front of you. All you have to do is reach in and take it. But do it quickly. The acid will dissolve the key in a matter of seconds. Over the past few years, you have become a shell of your former self, consumed with hatred and vengeance. Vengeance against the drunk driver who killed your only son. Vengeance against the killer who, to your surprise and dismay, was set free after a hasty trial.

Today, however, it will be you who will be put on trial. To escape from where you are, you will have to face a series of tests. You will have to suffer to move through each of them. But with each one, you will have a chance-- a chance to forgive. When you complete the tests, I promise you will finally come face-to-face with the man responsible for the loss of your child.

That will be your ultimate test. Can you forgive him? You better hurry, though. In two hours, the doors will lock and this place will become your tomb. This is what you've been waiting for, Jeff. In the past three years, you've cursed the names of all those you thought were responsible for the death of your son. You fantasized those accountable will pay.

Well, in this room you will find a woman in front of you chained in place. This will prevent her from running Her name is Danica Scott. She was the only witness present at the scene of your son's untimely demise. If not for her own self-absorption and cowardice, she could have brought your son's killer to justice. Now it is you who has a chance to bring her to justice.

You alone can grant her the gift of life before she freezes to death. Behind the pipes on the back wall, you will find the key that will free her and bring you one step closer to the man responsible for the loss of your child. Will you claim the key to save only yourself, or can you find it within you to save another? Now you have the power to sentence his soul straight to hell.

Or you can forgive. The key that will free him is hidden inside your son's possessions. Possessions you have clung to for far too long. Now, if you flip the switch on the incinerator beneath you, a fire will cleanse you of this obsession and destroy them all, leaving only the key remaining. It is also the key that will bring you closer to the man accountable for taking your child. He doesn't have much time, Jeff.

If you're listening to this, that means that the confrontation you so long dreamed of is finally unfolding. In your head, he is a cipher, a symbol of your life changing. A symbol of death. I present him to you now as a simple human being.

His name is Timothy Young. He is 27 years old, a medical student with a mother and a father just like you. A man whose life also changed the day your son died. That day, he made a terrible mistake. You believed he didn't pay for that mistake, and now is your chance to make him pay.